Discuss '09 Star Wars Fan Movies
So the fanboys and fangirls did their part and expanded the Star Wars universe with their unique visions. And the winners have been chosen. Now do your part, Jedi movie critics let ‘em know what you think.   Check out the awesome flicks HERE!
blog
Atom | Topic | Discuss '09 Star Wars Fan Movies
 
 
Discussion

So the fanboys and fangirls did their part and expanded the Star Wars universe with their unique visions. And the winners have been chosen. Now do your part, Jedi movie critics let ‘em know what you think.

 

Check out the awesome flicks HERE!

 
 
 
85%
 
 
 
 
Comments
Hi Guest, Log In or Sign Up to comment.

Jeff Capone Jeff Capone commented | 3 months ago
 
If you enjoyed the STAR SPORTS theatrical trailer, we invite you to check out the feature-length movie production. The season is now complete with 10 action-packed episodes, blooper reels, promotional artwork, and much more @ www.youtube.com/MHSVideographyOnline
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
TishoDulev TishoDulev commented | 3 months ago
 
Does anyone know how to determine the finalists? How many movies have applied?
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
spazweez spazweez commented | 3 months ago
 
Hey guys, just curious if anyone has received their passes yet?
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
daveandtom daveandtom commented | 3 months ago
 
See you there we look forward to meeting you and trading war stories!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Joe Presswood Joe Presswood commented | 3 months ago
 
And the voting is over as quickly as it began! I enjoyed it and look forward to Comic Con!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
JabbaTheTruth JabbaTheTruth commented | 4 months ago
 
looks like Atom installed the new profile system. You can now check out all the profiles and see who voted for what or who saw what. Interesting.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
DarthMilan DarthMilan commented | 4 months ago
 
Knights of the Old Republic:Revan is the best by alot I mean the story was undoutably best the armor amazing best force powers lightsaber dueling good (the good thing about that is that when a jedi and sith with its not just lightsaber and martial fighting force powers should take up more than half ot the fighting) also just the fact that Revan is there is just way grand for me :D I adore KotOR I and The Dark Lord of the Sith :) But that may be just me ;P
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Oscar Triana Oscar Triana commented | 4 months ago
 
Jabba, you are not alone.... there are some threads here and there about the situation and some of the points you made have been discussed too:

http://community.atom.com/Discussion-Thread/BRING-BACK-THE-SERIOUS-FILMS--DOCUMENTARIES/03EFBFFFF00E953E90009009D9B65

http://boards.theforce.net/fan_films_fan_audio_scifi_3d_forum/b10015/30098286/p3

About the "friends-comment" trend that you suggest, i don´t know what to say... my real friends hardly make 10 votes and 20 views (I appreciate their support, don´t worry :))... and gladly, my actual stats are way beyond that number...(btw thanks to all the people all over the globe for their time!) I suppose there are better cases with more friends and family but the popular entries, the ..hmmm.. "web hits" are made by one guy sending the link to another, and that one to his friends, and so on, or posting on a blog, digg, on your webpage, forum, where you can find more feedback, for all tastes. ;)
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
JabbaTheTruth JabbaTheTruth commented | 4 months ago
 
Alright so this contest is almost over and I have to say I'm dissappointed over the views and reviews of this contest. After all this is a major franchise and it should be getting more views. It did in the past. Retold, fate of Duel is getting tons of views on others channels. Here, they are nothing more then a blip. Hardly noticed. This changed when Atom changed last year, don't see the viewers here anymore.
As far as the reviews, with the exception of a handul of reviewers, most are just friends who chime in on their buddies flick and say great job. All you have to do is check their profile...Dragon below me for example. Nothing wrong with that. But it would have been nice to see all the filmmakers create a fake profile and review each film honestly in this contest. Not vote, just review. That would have given each filmmaker 21 solid reviews. I believe at the end of the day that is what most of the filmmakers are here for. An honest view of their work, stuff that worked, that didn't. Not to late guys, you can still do this....I'm sure some of the filmmakers already have. No one else is going to do it, with the exception of friends, no one else is watching these things. Atom needs to step up or they will lose this franchise.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Dragon Dragon commented | 4 months ago
 
I loved Blasted Behavior! Funny, smart, and just the right amount of pathos to honor George Lucas' classic characters. C'mon doesn't this express what we were all think when watching the Star Wars movies -- "This is one screwed up family." :-)
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Atom Atom commented | 4 months ago
 
An update on the voting, for anyone who wants to change their vote, or for Atom members who share a computer with another Atom member. Some browsers require you to delete the cookies before it will let you log in and vote again (i.e. recast your vote) or before it will let a new user sign in and vote on the same browser.

We will still only count one vote per Atom member the last vote you cast.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
spazweez spazweez commented | 4 months ago
 
-- China endorses "Glen Eisley Glen Mos!" --

China has officially recognized "Glen Eisley Glen Mos" with a bootleg link on a Chinese Star Wars fan bbs (http://www.starwarsbbs.cn/thread-3519-1-1.html), where poster/state-sponsored cinema reviewer "Lightsaber (Sexy Shoeless God of War)" has showered the film with praise! He gushes (according to Alta Vista's Babelfish):

"Very happy, but has not understood the literary reference!"
"A little looks like the Nicolas basket. ... Graciousness, the basket is quite valiant!"
and
"Possibly I need orphaned dog!"

There you have it! All of China can't be wrong! (Human rights and environmental issues aside.) So vote for "Glen Eisley Glen Mos" today!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
spazweez spazweez commented | 4 months ago
 
Finalist? Sweet. Totalfan's list? Double sweet. I enjoyed "Fate of the Duel." No surprise -- DaveAndTom are usually funny. And I've gotta say, the more I watch "Star Sports," the easier it is to just kick back and enjoy the ride.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
daveandtom daveandtom commented | 4 months ago
 
Who has had a chance to see to watch Star Wars The Fate Of The Duel? Dave and I will see you at comic-con.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Joe Presswood Joe Presswood commented | 4 months ago
 
Well, my tickets should be coming in the mail. Tried to buy some more tickets through lucasfilm but that wasn't happening. Sucks comic con was already sold out before the finalists knew they had even made the competition. But...it is great to have two free tickets to the show. I thank comic con and Lucasfilm for that. So my brother and I will be there!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
daveandtom daveandtom commented | 4 months ago
 
Totalfan Fair enough thanks for being cool. We thought it was snarky because you posted it on the films that weren't on the list but we are wrong you were just posting on all the films. Fair enough
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
RichieRich RichieRich commented | 4 months ago
 
I was incredibly hurt and disgusted by your list. #2, second best... come on! You are clearly bias to animation and that is profiling my friend!!JK
Honestly, stop worrying about others peoples feelings; the fact that someone actually watched my video is an honor in itself. Also, post your video that didn't get in, so we can see it. Thanks for watching mine and commenting on it.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
totalfan3000 totalfan3000 commented | 4 months ago
 
Hey everyone,
Recently I went down the list of films and posted my personal top 10 list. The purpose was to drum up some coversation about all the films and possably, maybe, hear other points of view on the subject. It would be really neat to hear other peoples oppinions...or heck, come up with your own lists for goodness sake! I did not mean to offend anyone by not putting their movie on my list but apparently I have. If their is anyone who feels slighted by my opinions then you have my apologies!!!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
Atom Atom commented | 4 months ago
 
Hey folks - it's great to see everyone is as excited about this year's challenge as we are! To clarify a few things:
1 - each Atom member gets one vote, and one vote only. "Your last vote is the one that counts" means that if you reload or close your browser and come back and vote for a different film, that's the one we will tally. Not your previous vote.
2 - You can vote for your favorite video all day long but we’re only counting one vote per customer. The last vote, to be exact.
3 - Voting and rating films are two different things. ALL the videos on our site can be rated. It has nothing to do with voting. Voting takes place on the voting page only.
4 - The "added" date on each video's landing page is not the same thing as the submission date.
5 - Engineering is looking into the intermittent sound issues that plagued some of our viewers.
6 - All of the finalists are listed in alphabetical order on the voting page so that it's easy for viewers to find the film they want to watch and vote for.

Good luck to all of the finalists and thanks for watching!
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse
 
 
 
MisLin MisLin commented | 4 months ago
 
I am surprised at some of the 'favourites' here. While there are some that are high quality, many are very weak on plot, two with no plot whatsoever. I voted for Blasted Behaviour because it was entertaining, included fan jokes and had a definite plot. My other favourites were the spoof outtakes and the girl who explained the movies. I hope you watched all the movies before choosing one.
 
Flag Copyright Report Abuse